New analysis finds fewer broad antibiotics after tooth-extraction guidelines in Japan
Claims data linked guideline changes with lower use of third-generation cephalosporins and lower antibiotic costs, while infection rates did not change.
Moderate evidenceHuman studySome caution advised
Medical disclaimer: This article summarizes research findings and is for informational purposes only. It is not medical advice.
Editorial illustration — not from the study.
The study examined whether guidelines favoring amoxicillin over third-generation cephalosporins for preventive antibiotic use during tooth extraction were followed by changes in prescribing, surgical-site infection rates, and antibiotic costs. Researchers compared trends before and after guideline changes in December 2014 and April 2016, using insurance claims from Japan.
Use of third-generation cephalosporins declined overall. The reduction began in hospitals after the 2014 guidance and became greater after the 2016 guidance in hospitals that had both infection-control departments and ward pharmacists. A decline began later in dental clinics. Infection rates stayed unchanged, while antibiotic costs decreased over time. The study does not establish that the guidelines alone produced these changes.
What was studied
Researchers used a Japanese health-insurance claims database covering dental visits for tooth extractions from April 2012 through March 2024 among people aged 75 or younger. They conducted an interrupted time-series analysis, a method that compares trends before and after a defined event, to examine the effects associated with antibiotic guidelines issued in December 2014 and April 2016. The analysis assessed use of third-generation cephalosporins, movement toward amoxicillin, surgical-site infection rates, antibiotic costs, and whether prescriptions were issued inside or outside hospitals. Results were also compared across facility types and according to whether hospitals had infection-control departments and ward pharmacists. The abstract does not report the total number of people or dental visits included.
Key observations
Overall, use of third-generation cephalosporins, measured as days of therapy, decreased during the study period. After the 2014 guideline, use decreased in hospitals but not in dental clinics. After the 2016 guideline, use fell further in hospitals that had both infection-control departments and ward pharmacists, and a decline began in dental clinics. Hospitals with infection-control departments alone did not show a change after the 2016 guideline. The shift toward amoxicillin was more apparent for prescriptions filled outside hospitals than for prescriptions given within hospitals. Surgical-site infection rates did not change, while antibiotic costs decreased significantly over time. These are associations in claims data; the abstract does not show that the guidelines directly caused every change.
Who this is relevant to
These findings may be most relevant to dental clinics and hospitals in Japan caring for people aged 75 or younger who undergo tooth extraction, particularly facilities with infection-control departments and ward pharmacists. They may not apply directly to older adults, people with different medical conditions, other countries, or healthcare systems with different prescribing practices. The results describe population-level trends and do not determine what is appropriate for any individual patient or procedure.
Why it matters
The findings suggest that antibiotic guidance may be associated with changes in prescribing and lower antibiotic costs without a detected increase in surgical-site infections in this dataset. They also suggest that the effect differed by facility type and may have been greater where infection-control staff and ward pharmacists worked together. The results may be relevant to efforts to understand antibiotic use around dental procedures, but they do not determine whether the same patterns would occur in other countries, healthcare systems, age groups, or patient populations.
Limitations & evidence assessment
The study was observational and had no randomized comparison group, so changes in prescribing or infection rates could also reflect other policies, staffing changes, changes in patient mix, or broader trends during 2012–2024. Claims data may not contain all clinical details needed to assess infection risk, the reason an antibiotic was prescribed, or whether patients actually took it. The abstract does not provide the sample size, detailed patient characteristics, the length of follow-up for each patient, or the specific statistical estimates and uncertainty ranges. It also reports results for people aged 75 or younger in Japan, which limits how broadly the findings can be applied. Although infection rates were unchanged, the study cannot establish that antibiotic reduction was risk-free for every individual.
Why this evidence level: This was a large health-insurance claims analysis of people undergoing tooth extraction, using an interrupted time-series design to compare patterns before and after guideline changes. Because it was not a randomized trial, other changes over time could have contributed to the findings, so it shows associations rather than definite cause and effect.
Evidence levels are editorial estimates derived from study metadata — they are not clinical appraisals.
// Source
Journal of Hospital Infection · 2026 · DOI: 10.1016/j.jhin.2026.08.004
This systematic review examined randomized trials of berberine in women with polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome, previously called polycystic ovary syndrome. Four trials involving 452 participants were identified, but all were judged to have a high risk of compromised integrity and were excluded from quantitative analysis. The researchers concluded that current evidence is insufficient to establish whether berberine is effective in this condition.
A systematic review and meta-analysis compared radiofrequency ablation with surgery and other heat-based procedures in 3,612 people with papillary thyroid carcinoma. Compared with surgery, radiofrequency ablation was associated with similar reported disease progression and fewer complications, but the evidence came from a limited number of studies and may not apply to all patients.
Researchers studied 514 mothers or caregivers of children aged 6–23 months attending three public health centers in Harar City, Eastern Ethiopia. They found that 61.5% of the children met the study’s minimum meal-frequency standard, while meeting that standard was associated with caregiver beliefs, household circumstances, breastfeeding status, child age, and other factors.
