Process-level uncertainties challenge system-level direct air capture assessments
Abstract
Abstract System-level assessments of direct air capture (DAC) commonly rely on individual process models, overlooking the influence of model choice on system-level conclusions. Here, we quantify this impact by integrating weather-dependent performance data from seven solid-sorbent DAC models into an otherwise consistent energy system framework. DAC representation is the largest source of variation in levelized CO2 capture cost, accounting for 43% of the observed variation across the climate-renewable archetypes considered compared with 16% for climate and 6% for renewable-resource configuration. Model-dependent cost differences exceed 1000 € tCO2-1 at individual locations. Different model representations can also reverse siting preferences, substantially alter cost-optimal system design, and determine whether future CO2 capture-cost targets are achieved. Our results further demonstrate how individual process-level assumptions can propagate through the assessment, resulting in a major source of system-level uncertainty. The harmonized DAC performance data developed here enable systematic comparison of alternative DAC representation in future system assessments.
// Source
Authors: Henrik Wenzel, M. Glaser, Mattia Galanti, Tom Terlouw, Daniel Rezo, Vittoria Bolongaro, Mak Dukan, Aaron Jajjawi, Jochen Linßen, Niall Mac Dowell, Sean McCoy, Russell McKenna, Ralf Peters, Thomas Schöb, Marwan Sendi, Martin van Sint Annaland, Niklas V. von der Assen, Carsten Wedler, Christoph Winkler, Jann Michael Weinand
Institutions: Saudi Aramco (Saudi Arabia), Imperial College London, University of Calgary, RWTH Aachen University, Eindhoven University of Technology, ETH Zurich, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Paul Scherrer Institute, Saudi Aramco (United States), Institute of Energy and Process Engineering