The team directed 10-femtosecond, 10-keV X-ray pulses from a free-electron laser at a 100-micrometre-thick zinc telluride crystal. They detected terahertz emission arising when different spectral components within each X-ray pulse mixed in the material.

The emission’s polarization and angle dependence indicated that the process involved two forms of X-ray difference-frequency generation, including one that can occur in materials with inversion symmetry. The results show that X-ray pulses can produce a rapidly changing nonlinear polarization in solids and provide a way to study these interactions.