Researchers evaluated Shijiazhuang’s 45-day “Sharp Sword to Cut Haze” campaign, which included temporary shutdowns in some heavy industries and restrictions on vehicle use. They combined weather-adjusted pollution data, comparisons with similar cities and machine-learning predictions to estimate what pollution would have been without the campaign.

The analysis found reductions in both local emission strength and measured pollutant concentrations. Independent analysis of PM2.5 chemical components also found lower contributions from vehicles, steelmaking and coal burning than during the comparable period in 2017. Even so, severe haze continued, pointing to the limits of action confined to one city.