Context‐Specific Montreal Cognitive Assessment Cutoffs for Cognitive Impairment in Parkinson's Disease
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) is widely used in Parkinson's disease (PD) research to measure cognition, but published cutoffs for mild cognitive impairment (PD-MCI) and dementia (PDD) vary. OBJECTIVE: To identify context-specific MoCA cutoffs for PD-MCI, PDD, and impairment on formal neuropsychological testing, and to assess whether combining MoCA with routinely collected clinical measures improves discrimination. METHODS: Data from 1094 people with PD were analyzed. 39.0% were diagnosed with PD-MCI, 6.2% with PDD. Normative ranges for five neuropsychological tests were derived from healthy controls. Mixed-effects logistic regression accounted for repeated measures and predicted (1) impairment on formal neuropsychological testing and (2) clinician-derived cognitive diagnoses. Cutoffs were derived using Youden's J, a prevalence-matching approach (cutoff where the proportion below threshold equals outcome prevalence), and standard screening and diagnostic criteria. RESULTS: Education-adjusted MoCA predicted impairment in two or more cognitive domains with an AUC of 0.86 (95% CI: 0.84-0.88). A cutoff of ≤24 maximized Youden's J (sensitivity 74.7% [70.5-79.3], specificity 83.1% [82.0-84.2]); the prevalence-matched cutoff was ≤21. For PD-MCI, the Youden's J cutoff was ≤25 and the prevalence-matched cutoff ≤24; PDD cutoffs were ≤23 and ≤17. Functional impairment (MDS-UPDRS 1.1) showed greater concordance with clinician-assigned diagnosis than MoCA alone. CONCLUSION: Optimal MoCA cutoffs vary by intended use. For research stratification, prevalence-matched cutoffs can align classification with observed outcome prevalence. Generalizability may be limited, particularly to routine clinical populations. Cutoffs derived in the PPMI cohort may over-identify impairment in broader populations.
// Source
Authors: Tanja Zerenner, Sanjay Manohar, Jamil Razzaque, Falah Al Hajraf, Karolien Groenewald, Ludo van Hillegondsberg, Jessica Welch, Tamir Eisenstein, Daniel Weintraub, Johannes Christian Klein, Yoav Ben‐Shlomo, Michele T Hu, Michael A Lawton
Institutions: University of Pennsylvania, Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre, University of Oxford, University of Bristol, Kuwait University