Researchers analyzed measurements of the cosmic microwave background, the clustering of galaxies and Type Ia supernovae using a model that allows dark energy’s behavior to change over time. They found that the standard cosmological model was disfavored at more than 3 standard deviations in favor of a dark energy history that crosses the so-called phantom divide.

The same pattern remained when data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument were replaced by expansion-rate measurements from the SH0ES project. The crossing occurred at different times depending on which datasets were combined, but models that allowed a crossing consistently fit the data best.