A two-year study found higher symptoms among adolescents with especially low or high reading skills, not those in the middle group.
Researchers followed 1,035 Finnish adolescents from Grade 7 to Grade 9, measuring reading fluency and comprehension with standardized tests and asking students about literacy-related emotions and psychological well-being. They identified three broad reading-skill paths: low comprehension with slowly increasing fluency, average-increasing skills, and high comprehension with strongly increasing fluency.
Students in the highest-reading-skill group reported more enjoyment, hope and pride related to literacy, and less anger, anxiety, hopelessness and shame than students in the other groups. Yet depressive symptoms were higher in both the lowest- and highest-skill groups than in the average group, and increased more quickly over the two school years. The study found no differences between the groups in life satisfaction.
Three reading paths
The study identified three developmental paths between Grades 7 and 9. About 11% of the adolescents had low reading comprehension and low, slowly increasing reading fluency; 59% had average-increasing comprehension and fluency; and 30% had high comprehension and high-increasing fluency.
Reading skills improved across all three groups, although students with the lowest skills fell further behind in reading-fluency development. The highest-performing group reported more literacy-related enjoyment, hope and pride, and less anger, anxiety, hopelessness and shame. Depressive symptoms were higher in both the low-skill and high-skill groups than in the average group, and rose faster from Grade 7 to Grade 9. The researchers describe this as a nonlinear association: depressive symptoms were elevated at both ends of the reading-skill range.
Why both ends matter
The findings suggest that reading support and student well-being cannot be considered only in relation to struggling readers. Students with particularly high reading skills also showed increased depressive symptoms over time, despite reporting more positive emotions about literacy.
The authors say schools should continue supporting reading fluency and comprehension during lower secondary education, while ensuring that students across the skill range have positive learning experiences and appropriately challenging tasks. The results also suggest that efforts to support adolescent well-being should consider students at both ends of the reading-skills spectrum.
Evidence and caveats
This was a longitudinal study of Finnish adolescents, with measurements taken in Grade 7 and Grade 9. The sample included 1,035 students, although 675 took part at both time points. Reading was assessed with standardized tests, while emotions, life satisfaction and depressive symptoms were reported by the students. The researchers used a statistical method called latent profile analysis to group adolescents according to their reading-skill patterns.
The study shows associations, not that reading skills caused depressive symptoms. The follow-up covered only two school years, and earlier factors that may have contributed to both reading development and well-being were not controlled for. Reading comprehension was measured with one text, and the reliability of that measure was modest in Grade 9. The participants came from two Finnish towns, and the sample was described as fairly representative of Finland, although the mothers were somewhat more educated than Finnish women of the same age.