A study using John Locke’s political philosophy argues that automated government must remain explainable, accountable and open to public challenge.
The article argues that AI-mediated governance creates a political problem, not only a technical or regulatory one. When systems make or shape decisions through processes that officials and citizens cannot meaningfully interpret, responsibility can become dispersed and public consent weakened.
Drawing on Locke’s view of government as a trust granted by free and equal people, the article proposes three conditions for legitimate algorithmic authority: intelligibility, fiduciary accountability and contestability. It discusses technological civic literacy, participatory oversight, audits, explanation rights and constitutional safeguards as ways institutions could support those conditions, while stressing that these are not a technical blueprint.
The proposed test for AI power
The article’s central argument is that government use of AI can undermine political legitimacy when citizens cannot understand the reasons behind decisions, determine who is answerable for them or challenge their effects. It describes this as a form of automated discretionary power: authority exercised without clear public authorization, explanation or recourse.
Its Lockean test is that algorithmically mediated power remains legitimate only when it is publicly understandable, politically accountable and open to challenge by the people subject to it. The article also argues that technical adjustments alone cannot restore legitimacy; institutional arrangements must preserve citizens’ ability to exercise judgment and give or withhold consent.
Why public challenge matters
The argument places explainability, responsibility and avenues for appeal at the constitutional core of AI governance rather than treating them as optional technical features. It suggests that rules for automated government should be judged by whether they preserve the relationship of trust between governors and governed.
This matters because AI systems can shape information, attention, communication and administrative decisions while making responsibility harder to locate. The article offers a philosophical basis for asking not only whether an AI system works, but whether its use remains answerable to the people affected by it.
What kind of evidence this is
This is a normative and interpretive article, not an empirical study. It reconstructs Locke’s political philosophy and applies ideas about reason, equality, consent and fiduciary trust to contemporary debates about algorithmic accountability and digital constitutionalism. It does not report experiments, surveys, case comparisons or tests of particular AI systems.
The proposed criteria identify conditions for legitimate algorithmic authority rather than providing a detailed implementation plan. The conclusion also notes that Locke’s accounts of labour and property leave further questions about AI-generated value, ownership and prosperity. The available excerpt does not develop those questions in full.
// Source
Philosophy & Technology · 2026 · DOI: 10.1007/s13347-026-01211-4
Authors: Wendy R. Simon
Institutions: Universitat Internacional de Catalunya