Engineering & Technologyarticle2026-10-19

A Multi-Criteria Sustainability Assessment of an Avocado Waste Biorefinery Using the SASWROIM Framework

Open access0 citations

Abstract

The increasing complexity of integrated biorefineries requires sustainability assessment approaches capable of supporting engineering decision-making beyond conventional economic evaluation. This study applies the Safety and Sustainability Weighted Return on Investment Metric (SASWROIM) to evaluate the redesign of a Hass avocado seed biorefinery by integrating inherent safety, thermodynamic, technical, environmental, and economic performance into a single decision-support metric. The redesigned configuration achieved a conventional ROI of 47.67%, compared with 37.58% for the baseline, while the Total Inherent Safety Index (ISI) decreased from 25 to 20 and the Potential Environmental Impact (PEI) output rate decreased from 23.2 to 20.0 PEI/h. Thermodynamic performance was represented by Specific Exergy Destruction (SED), which decreased from 196.31 to 65.83 MJ/kg of feed, corresponding to a 66.5% reduction in exergy destruction intensity. In contrast, the Wastewater Production Ratio (WPR) increased from 39.8% to 86.35%, identifying water management as the principal technical limitation of the redesigned configuration. Under equal weighting, the combined normalized contributions resulted in a SASWROIM of 59.59%, exceeding the conventional ROI of 47.67% and indicating a net positive sustainability adjustment under the nominal assessment conditions. Sensitivity analyses showed that SASWROIM remained positive across the explored weighting, normalization-target, and scenario-based uncertainty conditions; however, technical-priority weighting and unfavorable combined uncertainty scenarios reduced the metric below the conventional ROI, indicating that the sustainability benefit is conditional on water-management performance and process variability. Overall, the results show that the redesign improved economic, inherent safety, exergy-destruction intensity, and environmental performance while introducing a significant trade-off in water management, highlighting SASWROIM as a transparent framework for identifying multidimensional sustainability priorities during conceptual biorefinery design.

// Source

View paper (DOI)Open access versionOpenAlexSustainabilityPublished 2026-10-19

Authors: Jesus David De Hoyos-Montiel, Segundo Rojas-Flores, Ángel Darío González-Delgado

Institutions: Universidad de Cartagena, Universidad César Vallejo