The review examined scholarship published from 1913 to 2025 on impeachment and similar accountability processes in four countries. After screening 921 records from six databases, the authors included 159 studies covering legal, political, comparative, qualitative, quantitative and mixed-method research.

The synthesis treats impeachment as both a legal accountability process and a political institution. It found that safeguards, credible evidence, independent trial bodies and cross-party deliberation are associated with accountability-oriented outcomes, while polarization, party-line voting, coalition bargaining, retaliation and strategic timing can push proceedings toward political instrumentalization.