A systematic review says impeachment works best with strong safeguards, credible evidence and cooperation across party lines.
The review examined scholarship published from 1913 to 2025 on impeachment and similar accountability processes in four countries. After screening 921 records from six databases, the authors included 159 studies covering legal, political, comparative, qualitative, quantitative and mixed-method research.
The synthesis treats impeachment as both a legal accountability process and a political institution. It found that safeguards, credible evidence, independent trial bodies and cross-party deliberation are associated with accountability-oriented outcomes, while polarization, party-line voting, coalition bargaining, retaliation and strategic timing can push proceedings toward political instrumentalization.
How impeachment functions
The review found that impeachment is neither purely legal nor purely political: its meaning and legitimacy are shaped by both constitutional rules and political behavior. The literature linked accountability-oriented outcomes with several conditions occurring together, including strong procedural safeguards, serious evidence, high voting thresholds, institutional independence, cross-party deliberation and respect for constitutional norms. The authors describe this as an association identified through thematic synthesis, not a causal relationship demonstrated by the review.
The review also identified recurring risks of partisan use, including polarization, party-line voting, coalition bargaining, retaliatory politics, strategic timing, media amplification and digital propaganda. Its country comparisons highlighted different vulnerabilities: formal safeguards in the United States may not prevent political deterioration when democratic norms weaken; high thresholds in France may limit overuse while displacing accountability; coalition dynamics in the Philippines may capture formal procedures; and parliamentary accountability in Italy may remain politically active but legally diffuse.
Why the safeguards matter
Impeachment is intended as an extraordinary response to serious constitutional wrongdoing, but the review suggests its legitimacy depends on how institutions and political actors use it. When legal standards appear to be applied selectively or legislative checks become partisan tools, the review links politicized impeachment with damage to the rule of law, separation of powers, democratic legitimacy and constitutional stability.
The findings therefore point to safeguards and institutional independence as important, but not sufficient on their own. Political restraint, cross-party deliberation and democratic norms also matter, meaning constitutional design alone cannot ensure that impeachment serves accountability rather than routine political conflict.
Evidence and caveats
This was a systematic literature review guided by PRISMA-informed identification and screening procedures. It covered six databases and included 159 studies after screening 921 records. The evidence base combined doctrinal legal scholarship, comparative constitutional analysis, empirical political research, case studies, quantitative work and mixed-method studies; the review did not collect new field data.
The review included only English-language literature and examined four jurisdictions, so its conclusions may not apply to other systems or may underrepresent scholarship in Filipino, French and Italian. The included studies used different methods and were not always directly comparable. A single reviewer selected and coded the studies, without independent dual coding. The thematic framework was also specified in advance, creating a risk that the synthesis favored the distinction between accountability and political instrumentalization rather than testing it against disconfirming evidence.
// Source
International Journal of Transformative Multidisciplinary Studies · 2026 · DOI: 10.66074/x9b2c5v7k
Authors: Gila Mae Sedoripa, Asterio Olandria
Institutions: Davao Oriental State University